Beekeeping is facing severe colony losses during the winter. Current beekeeping practices are now unbalanced in the face of the growing number of stress factors to which bee colonies are nowadays exposed. Therefore, there is an urgent need to reconsider current beekeeping management approaches. To give the transition to a new management model a chance of success, two objectives must be pursued: the creation of more resilient honey bees and safeguarding high honey yields. The Better-B consortium has developed a concept that meets these two requirements. Its central thought is the separation of production and reproduction in its conceptual model. The requirements the reproduction unit must meet, in particular, are clearly described. For the production unit, on the other hand, the beekeeper has much more freedom of action. The concept emerged from a critical analysis of the challenges involved and the relevant scientific literature; validation is currently underway.
Genetic variation may influence how honey bees respond to insecticides, yet it remains largely overlooked in pesticide risk assessment. By analysing honey bee genomes from 54 countries, our study identified 154 non-rare mutations in seven major insecticide target sites and identified ten mutations that may alter sensitivity to insecticides. These findings highlight differences among honey bee populations and reveal potential trade-offs between insecticide resistance and normal receptor function. We recommend incorporating diverse genetic backgrounds into pesticide risk assessment, promoting genetic diversity, and investigating the broader genetic mechanisms underlying insecticide sensitivity. The high-throughput TaqMan assay developed in this study provides a practical tool for screening European honey bee populations, helping inform more representative risk assessments and targeted pesticide management strategies.
Honey bees face severe threats from pathogens and climate change. Maintaining genetic diversity in honey bee populations is fundamental to their ability to adapt to these threats. Safeguarding genetic adaptation of honey bees to their local environments is especially important, as locally adapted honey bee strains show increased mortality when moved to new environments to which they are maladapted. Through large-scale genome sequencing as part of the Better-B project, we have uncovered the genetic consequences of extensive human-mediated transport of honey bees over the past century. We also identified signals of both ancient and recent natural selection, pointing to molecular mechanisms underlying local adaptation. In addition, we analysed genetic variation in populations experiencing ongoing natural selection for Varroa resistance, finding that these populations do not show reduced genetic variation.
Varroa destructor remains a major cause of honey bee colony losses in Europe, highlighting the need for more sustainable solutions. Within BETTER-B, we are testing the Darwinian Black Box protocol (Blacquière et al., 2019), which aims to establish locally adapted, Varroa-resilient populations through natural selection. Although the protocol has supported a honey bee population that has survived without Varroa treatment for 17 years in the Netherlands, its application across eight European countries revealed substantial regional differences in colony survival. Our case study shows that the protocol should be adapted to local conditions by reducing other stressors and balancing Varroa selection pressure with the survival of enough colonies to continue selection over successive generations. In this Practical Recommendation, the protocol that emerged from our study is provided.
Increasingly frequent droughts and extreme temperatures create additional challenges for bee colonies and beekeepers. The effects of climate change and extreme weather events could be mitigated by focused innovations in hive structure and properties, and apiary organization. Based on field measurements, technical characterization and beekeeper surveys, practical tools for beekeepers are provided: hive or apiary modifications can be used to modulate heat or moisture exchanges according to local environmental conditions. The aim is to improve colony resilience while remaining compatible with diverse beekeeping practices and objectives (e.g., cool/warm the hive).